Two homes on Beachside Drive in Orchid Island are listed on the same street, under the same gate and with the same club membership. As of mid-November, 7 Beachside Drive is a 4,651-square-foot courtyard home with a separate guest cabana, a short walk from the ocean. Its asking price is $2,995,000, which works out to about $644 a square foot. Farther up the road, 211 Beachside Drive is an 11,604-square-foot oceanfront estate on 1.27 acres with 122 feet of Atlantic frontage. It is listed at $18,750,000, about $1,616 a square foot.
Both houses are on the same street, but buyers are pricing them very differently. Inside this ocean-to-river community, frontage on the Atlantic separates one price per foot from another more than square footage or a fairway view does. A buyer who compares Orchid Island against other club communities using one blended median will miss that.
The Golf Side Has Been Closing Below $1,000 a Foot
Recent closings away from the ocean fall in a fairly tight band. The most recent is 602 Heron Point Court, a 2007 golf estate designed by architect Harry Howle that looks onto the 4th fairway. It closed on September 2, 2026, at $4,700,000 after listing at $4,995,000. At 5,553 square feet, that comes to about $846 a foot.
The three closings before it, from mid-2025 to fall 2025, landed in the same range:
| Address | Closed | Price | Size | Per sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 602 Heron Point Court | Sept. 2, 2026 | $4,700,000 | 5,553 | ~$846 |
| 520 White Pelican Circle | Oct. 31, 2025 | $4,750,000 | 4,792 | ~$991 |
| 331 Westwind Court | Sept. 12, 2025 | $2,647,500 | 3,603 | ~$735 |
| 512 White Pelican Circle | June 5, 2025 | $3,175,000 | 3,933 | ~$807 |
The high end of that range is 520 White Pelican Circle, a four-bedroom home built in 2025 on a 0.74-acre lot with golf-course views. It was new construction and still closed just under $1,000 a foot. The others closed between roughly $735 and $846.
For context, MLS sales in Orchid Island over the three years through September 2, 2026, had a median of $816 a square foot, a median of 24 days on market and a 95% list-to-sale ratio. Those figures cover recorded MLS sales only, not private ones. The golf-side closings in the table sit around that median.
Beachside Drive Is Listed Above $1,000 a Foot
Orchid Island's oceanfront condominiums are low-rise buildings on top of the dunes. According to the club, its condos run from about 2,200 to 3,800 square feet. Over the last few weeks, every Beachside Drive condo listed has been priced at about $1,000 a foot or more.
As of November 16, 70 Beachside Drive #103 was listed at $2,500,000 for 2,252 square feet with three bedrooms and ocean views. That is about $1,110 a foot. The penthouse at 90 Beachside Drive #301 is 3,309 square feet listed at $3,700,000, about $1,118 a foot, and it is under contract. At 30 Beachside Drive #201, 3,810 square feet with a study is pending at a $3,800,000 asking price, just under $1,000 a foot.
Two of those three condos were under contract or pending by mid-November. The final prices will show up once they close.
Oceanfront estates take the same pattern further. When 211 Beachside Drive sold in March 2023, the price was $13,000,000, about $1,120 a foot. Its current $18,750,000 asking price would be about $1,616 a foot. The club describes its oceanfront estate homes as a limited set at the north end of its private beach. With so few of them, each one that comes to market tests what the frontage is worth on its own.
7 Beachside Drive, the home from the opening, fits the pattern too. It has the Beachside address and is a short walk from the sand, but it isn't oceanfront. At $644 a foot, it is listed below every golf-side home that has closed recently.
Same Building, Same Size, Two Prices
The closest comparison in the community is inside 70 Beachside Drive. Unit #203 is 2,252 square feet with three bedrooms, three baths and a wraparound porch facing south. It was listed at $2,300,000 and sold for $2,135,000 after 423 days on the market, about $948 a foot. MLS records date that closing to January 30, 2026.
Unit #103 in the same building has the same 2,252 square feet and is now listed at $2,500,000. That is about 17% above what #203 sold for this year.
Even at $948, the #203 sale was close to the top of the golf-side range, so the oceanfront premium is real. Some of the gap between oceanfront asking prices and golf-side closing prices is also just the difference between what sellers ask and what buyers pay. #203 took more than a year to sell, while the community-wide median over three years was 24 days. The condo sales that went pending this fall will show how much of that gap buyers have closed.
What Pushes a Golf-Side Home Higher
The golf side has an outlier. 828 Pembroke Court is a 3,061-square-foot home with lake and fairway views, pending at a $3,700,000 asking price. That is about $1,209 a foot, above several of the oceanfront condos. Its listing describes the home as completely updated. Along with 520 White Pelican Circle, the 2025 build that set the top of the closed range, it shows the second thing driving prices away from the ocean. A home in move-in condition can approach the ocean-side price per foot even without the frontage.
70 Caribe Way, a 2,815-square-foot pool home on a cul-de-sac, is listed at $2,700,000, about $959 a foot. It sold for $950,000 in May 2021. Few properties in the community show the change in the market more clearly.
The river side is still unsettled. Vero News featured 545 White Pelican Circle in October. It is a 5,564-square-foot custom home with estuary views, a private dock and a separate two-bedroom guest house. At its $4,500,000 asking price, it would be about $809 a foot, in the golf-side range. For now that is an asking price, not a recorded sale, so the river side has no recent closed price per foot.
The Club Is Investing on the Ocean Side Too
The price per foot is only part of what a buyer pays. Orchid Island is member-owned, and membership is tied to owning a home. The club offers equity memberships and a limited number of invitational memberships, and buyers must apply and be approved. The club treats membership as a separate financial commitment from the home purchase. The club's comparison guide lists a golf membership at $135,000 and labels its prices approximate and subject to change. Anyone budgeting for a purchase should confirm current membership costs directly with the club. This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and each buyer's situation should be confirmed with the right professional.
The club's next big capital project is on the beach. On November 3, the club announced an $8.2 million Beach Club renovation. In the first phase, scheduled to open in December, the Seaside Lounge grows from 1,500 to 3,900 square feet, with five large windows facing the Atlantic. A 4,100-square-foot beachfront spa and two new Beach Suites are scheduled for spring 2027. Peacock & Lewis Architecture of North Palm Beach is designing the project. In the announcement, General Manager Rob Tench called the Beach Club "the jewel of Orchid Island."
Before this, the club completed a $5 million Golf Club renovation, added the Pelican Pavilion, expanded its racquet and recreation amenities and renovated the Arnold Palmer-designed course. The golf side's facilities are already finished. The ocean side's are being finished over this winter and next spring, in the stretch of beach where the Beachside Drive condos and estates sit.
For a buyer, a home's location in this community affects more than the view. It sets which price-per-foot range the home falls in and how close it is to where the club is spending next. If golf and tennis are why you're looking, our earlier guide on why golf and tennis buyers choose Orchid Island covers that side, and the Orchid Island vs. John's Island comparison puts the club next to its closest peer.
Questions Buyers Ask About Orchid Island Pricing
Is Orchid Island's median price per square foot a useful benchmark? It works for the golf side. Over the three years through September 2, 2026, the MLS median was $816 a foot, and recent golf-side closings landed near it. Oceanfront condos and estates have been listed well above it this fall, so a blended figure understates the ocean side and overstates a home like 7 Beachside Drive.
What sizes and types of homes are inside the gate? According to the club, its condominiums are generally about 2,200 to 3,800 square feet, and its single-family homes run from about 2,500 to more than 6,000. The single-family homes include custom estates, courtyard homes and cottages on cul-de-sacs and winding streets. Current listings and recent sales in the community are on our Orchid Island homes for sale page.
When does the new Seaside Lounge open? The club has scheduled the expanded lounge to open in December 2026 and the spa and Beach Suites for spring 2027.
If you own on Beachside Drive or along the fairways and want to know which of these price ranges your home falls in, Team Provancher can price it against the Orchid Island closings and listings above, address by address. Start with our instant home valuation, and we'll follow up with a market read specific to your home.